How The Gilded Age Brought Oscar and Enid van Rhijn’s Salon to Life

The HBO drama’s Emmy-nominated production designer, Bob Shaw, takes us inside the art-filled soirée, plus Peggy’s wedding

Blake Ritson and Kelley Curran as Oscar and Enid in The Gilded Age
Blake Ritson and Kelley Curran as Oscar and Enid in The Gilded Age. Photo: Courtesy of Karolina Wojtasik/HBO

Christine Baranski’s Agnes van Rhijn wouldn’t approve, but we certainly do.

In the third episode of The Gilded Age’s fourth season, Agnes’s not-out son, Oscar, and his clever, wealthy wife of convenience, Enid, take a major step in their plan to create a “new and novel society” by hosting a salon featuring the paintings of American Impressionist William Merritt Chase (1849-1916).

Production designer Bob Shaw and his team staged the home of the aspiring power couple, played by Blake Ritson and Kelley Curran, in Reid Castle, an 1892 landmark by Stanford White that now stands on the campus of Manhattanville University in Purchase, New York. Shaw had filmed the location years ago when he needed a hotel double for another HBO drama, Boardwalk Empire. This time, he lined the dining room—a masterpiece in its own right beneath a coffered ceiling—with reproductions of Chase’s real works. “It was originally written to be Winslow Homer,” Shaw reveals, “but as much as I may admire his work, it did not seem romantic or sexy enough.”

Harry Richardson as Larry Russell and Ben Ahlers as Jack Trotter
Harry Richardson as Larry Russell and Ben Ahlers as Jack Trotter. Photo: Courtesy of Karolina Wojtasik/HBO

Chase’s reputation as a society portraitist had made him a candidate to paint Gladys Russell last season (that fictional honor went to John Singer Sargent instead). So the artist’s oeuvre was already familiar to Shaw, who estimates more than 50 pieces were photographed, printed to size, and painted over, including At the Seaside (1892), Idle Hours (1894), and Azaleas (c. 1882), the still life purchased in the episode by Jack Trotter, the footman turned inventor played by Ben Ahlers. For that volume of work, and the inclusion of “living art”—actors mimicking the poses of select paintings, such as The Mandolin Player (c. 1878-9) and 1890’s dancing Carmencita—Shaw had to take liberties with Season 4’s 1886 timeline.

“These things are always commented upon online, and I appreciate everyone’s concern for authenticity,” the designer says with a laugh, “but I really try not to read those things because I know that it’s hard to represent these artists. I know it’s hard to have something look like it was painted by Sargent. We had the same thing when we were starting the show, because the portrait of Bertha Russell was supposed to look like it was done by Giovanni Boldini, who had this very loose brushwork. They referred to him as the Master of Swish even back in the day, and to look at the [reproduction] as it was progressing and say, ‘No, looser, freer, looser and freer’… To have to channel somebody’s exact style is very, very difficult.”

For the work of Chase’s fictional protégé Lee Klein, played by James Scully, Shaw employed the paintings of another American Impressionist, John Henry Twachtman, whose 1885 French landscape Arques-la-Bataille serves as the backdrop for a flirtatious tête-à-tête between Klein and Oscar.

Curran, Ritson, and James Scully as Lee Klein
Curran, Ritson, and James Scully as Lee Klein. Photo: Courtesy of Karolina Wojtasik/HBO

Enid expresses concern that the addition of living art may “tip the balance between tasteful and tawdry.” Shaw concedes that The Gilded Age creator Julian Fellowes did have to rein in his department when they suggested reenacting 1888’s Back of a Nude. “Julian was not in favor of that,” he recalls with a laugh. But, as the designer also notes, “Real tableau vivant was this excuse to have nudity or at least show more skin. The curtain would open and here is Venus of Urbino, oh my god! But the rule was [the figures] couldn’t be moving; they literally had to be a tableau. We borrowed from that idea, and then since [our performers] were clothed, it didn’t seem like they needed to be frozen. That was a little bit of a cheat.”

Shaw must always balance a desire for historical accuracy with the need to appeal to modern eyes. He’s largely avoided the traditional gallery-style walls in homes until this salon presented a reason to embrace them: “It was standard for the time period to have three, and sometimes even four, layers of paintings. They would just put a painting every place you could put something,” Shaw says. “But when a contemporary viewer looks at that, it just appears overcrowded and messy. So we [usually] pull back and have two layers of paintings. Just like we don’t have as many piano shawls. We don’t have quite as many layers of lace.”

Curran, with Ashlie Atkinson as Mrs. Fish
Curran, with Ashlie Atkinson as Mrs. Fish. Photo: Courtesy of Karolina Wojtasik/HBO

One design choice Shaw was willing to gamble with was the edible sugar cherub sculpture that gossip queen Mrs. Fish, played by Ashlie Atkinson, samples from the banquet table. “We had a lot of discussion about that, because when you look at it, how do you know that it’s edible?” he says of the period touch. “Obviously, we wouldn’t think she’d be chewing on plaster, but hopefully people figure that out. It was easier for her to break off a spun-sugar flower than snap off a hand.”

Four seasons into the show, Shaw and his team still find ways to keep things fresh. That could be as simple as forcing Agnes to adjust to the new curtains her sister, Cynthia Nixon’s Ada, added to their home in the season’s second hour (the silk Chinoiserie in burnt orange was provided by Artéé Fabrics & Home). Or, perhaps it’s getting to check a location off of their filming wish list. For Episode 3’s other big event, the wedding of writer-activist Peggy Scott and Dr. William Kirkland, played by Denée Benton and Jordan Donica, Shaw reserved St. Paul’s Episcopal Church in Troy, N.Y.—a late-19th century building he’d been eyeing for its Tiffany Glass and Decorating Company windows since before cameras rolled on the first season.

Denée Benton and Jordan Donica as Peggy and William
Denée Benton and Jordan Donica as Peggy and William. Photo: Courtesy of Karolina Wojtasik/HBO

“We do these weddings, and it’s always white, white, white, white, white. So because Peggy had previously been married and had a child, and therefore wasn’t a virgin, we could introduce color into the flowers,” Shaw says. “It was very exciting for us to be able to have a palette of peach, rose, and other jewel tones to pick up the colors in the church.”

St. Paul’s Episcopal Church in Troy, NY
St. Paul’s Episcopal Church in Troy, N.Y. Photo: Courtesy of Karolina Wojtasik/HBO

Because the ceremony was filmed over several days, a mix of artificial roses, dahlias, spider mums, poppies, and begonia leaves were used along with real oncidium orchids and smilax. “We have a wonderful floral designer, Tess Casey, who conspires with her our set decorator, Jenny Alex Nickason, who happens to be an amazing gardener and can identify exotic flowers from 50 paces,” Shaw says.
Floralscapes are another instance where liberties will be taken on occasion. “When you look at historic photos, their idea of lavish was just more carnations,” he says. “So again, it does not read opulent to the contemporary viewer.”