Style

Nickey Kehoe’s Founders Share Their Holiday Wish Lists

Channeling the same craft-focused aesthetic that has made their Los Angeles-born brand a must-follow, Todd Nickey and Amy Kehoe reveal a thoughtful selection of treasured goods

By Jill Sieracki

November 13, 2025

A man and woman pose in a stylish room surrounded by decorative items, including a jug, earrings, and a decorative cloth.

As the founders of Nickey Kehoe, Amy Kehoe and Todd Nickey have cultivated a distinct style that emphasizes the handmade, curating personality filled home goods destined to be future heirlooms. From their Los Angeles flagship, the duo have built a collection of artisan-made furniture, lighting, tableware, and more that they layer with exceptional vintage finds.

It’s an aesthetic so coveted, it sparked tastemakers to seek out their skills for designing bespoke residential interiors. Today, they also oversee an assortment of Nickey Kehoe furniture, lighting, and wallpaper as well as collaborations with House of Hackney and Dumais Made. Recently, the brand migrated east, establishing a location in Greenwich Village, New York.

Here, the duo turn their attention to holiday shopping, selecting unique items sure to pique the interest of aesthetes everywhere.

Man and woman posing together in a sunlit room with large window, plants, and artwork in background. — Amy Kehoe and Todd Nickey, founders of Nickey Kehoe. Photo: Courtesy of Nickey Kehoe

Still life of pomegranates and decorative clay sculptures on a marble surface with ornate background. — Melograno in Scented Terracotta from Santa Maria Novella. Photo: Courtesy of Santa Maria Novella

1. Santa Maria Novella Scented Pomegranate

“I received my first terracotta pomegranate from Todd many years back. The terracotta pomegranate is a beautiful, enduring way to give the gift of scent.”—Amy Kehoe

Colorful square scarf with a pattern of tigers and pink vines on a dark background, bordered with orange and red designs. — Black Tigers Print Wool-Silk Bandana by Drake’s. Photo: Courtesy of Drake’s

2. Drake’s Bandana

“Chic and easy way to spice up any outfit—I’ve got a few, and they make a day-to-evening outfit perk right up.”—Todd Nickey

Chocolate brownies with chocolate chips on parchment paper. — Gluten-free, vegan Feelings brownies from Knead Love. Photo: Courtesy of Knead Love

3. Knead Love Brownies

“Our dear friend creates these irresistible gluten-free treats. They’re so hard to put down!”—A.K.

Seven tall brass candlesticks with unlit candles against a backdrop of architectural sketches. — RW Guild Reed candlesticks. Photo: Courtesy of RW Guild

4. RW Guild Candlesticks

“Sculptural and functional, I love these for adding ambiance to a room or intimate lighting for dining.”—T.N.

Gold and maroon crescent-shaped earrings embellished with silver rhinestones against a white background. — Twin Comet earrings by Maison Mayle. Photo: Courtesy of Maison Mayle

5. Maison Mayle Jewelry

“Maison Mayle’s chic jewelry collection straddles day to evening, classic and cool. It’s certain to delight the recipient.”—A.K.

Six clear glass tumblers with frosted star patterns arranged in two rows on a white background. — Will’s Wine Glass set in Indigo. Photo: Courtesy of William White

6. William White Glassware

“Will Cooper’s new shop on Canal Street in New York is a sweet surprise. I love these chic indigo glasses for a signature cocktail.”—T.N.

Two closed books with plain covers; one has a small fox illustration, the other a small duck illustration, on a white background. — Le Typographe Mega Notepad. Photo: Courtesy of Goods for the Study

7. Le Typographe Notepad

“As a lifelong list maker, jotting down to-dos on these attractive notepads takes list-making to the next level.”—A.K.

Cream-colored blanket draped over a beige sofa with wooden legs on a wooden floor. — Nickey Kehoe mohair throw. Photo: Courtesy of Nickey Kehoe

8. Nickey Kehoe Mohair Throw

“Cozy up in one of our mohair throws. A crowd-pleasing cozy gift.”—T.N.

Red bandana with intricate white paisley design and navy border on a plain background. — Trio Tenjiku Flower Bandana from 45R. Photo: Courtesy of 45R

9. 45R Bandana

“Another introduction from Todd years and years ago, I am now a devout client. Their pieces are so well-made. Bandanas from them are an easy addition to a wardrobe and super special.”—A.K.