Jeweler Margot McKinney Introduces a Dazzling Fifth Avenue Flagship
The Australian designer is the fourth-generation member of the McKinney jewelry family
There’s a new reason to window-shop on Fifth Avenue, and it’s sparkling. Renowned high jewelry designer Margot McKinney has officially opened the doors to her newest boutique in New York City.
Located across the street from Central Park’s Grand Army Plaza, the fourth-generation Australian jeweler is debuting her flagship store, bringing her exuberant and one-of-a-kind collections to the forefront. The salon, encompassing two floors in the storied Sherry-Netherland, occupies a rare surviving 1984 retail façade by Michael Graves & Associates, originally created for Diane von Furstenberg.
Inside, the boutique has been completely rebuilt by McKinney, designed in partnership with Tom Postma Design, with whom she had previously worked for at TEFAF Maastricht. The designer’s instinct was to preserve the personality of the site while creating a boutique that feels more like a private salon than a conventional retail space: intimate, layered, and designed around conversation, discovery, and storytelling.
It was also important to McKinney that her new space felt distinctly New York and different from her other retail spaces in Beverly Hills and Brisbane, while still preserving the personality and ethos of the brand. A refined medium blue adorns the walls, while the ceiling is painted in Wedgwood blue, a particular favorite of McKinney’s mother, bringing a sentimental touch to the design. Velvet drapes frame the room and draw the eye upward to the double-height ceiling, while hand-embroidered silk wall coverings add another layer of texture and luxury.
Despite its elegance, the salon felt anything but impersonal. The balustrade and stair handrail closely echo the veranda ironwork of the building McKinney’s great-grandfather established in Toowoomba in 1884. That building was both the family’s jewelry store and their home, with McKinney’s great-grandparents once living there, and both her grandfather and father being born there. More than 140 years later, that familiar pattern has found its way quietly into the architecture of the Fifth Avenue atelier–a subtle thread connecting the family’s beginnings in Queensland with its newest home.
One of the boutique’s most unexpected features is a sculptural bar with a polished golden exterior that opens to reveal a fully stocked interior. Reflecting the space’s residential, salon-like feel, it invites guests to sit, enjoy a drink, and discover the jewelry and stories behind it. McKinney’s close friend, renowned New York style arbiter Christopher Hyland, helped develop the textile palette, including a special gaufraged velvet in her signature green. Together, they curated an eclectic mix of furnishings, from a handcrafted 1950s Spanish chaise to pieces spanning different periods and places.
Housed in the iconic Sherry-Netherland, the landmark 1927 hotel-residence, the boutique blends old New York glamour with architectural history. Working with Acheson Doyle Partners Architects, McKinney transformed the former Geoffrey Beene storefront, preserving and restoring its distinctive Postmodern façade, for a new chapter in luxury jewelry.
Ultimately, the space is a backdrop for McKinney’s extraordinary jewelry creations. Known for an exuberant combination of scale, texture, and color–often built around important Australian South Sea pearls and opals surrounded by colored gemstones–her pieces are unique, and often take years to assemble. The designer’s longstanding connections with her pearl farmer, Aji Ellies, miners, gem cutters, and craftspeople, allow each jewel to carry a traceable human story as well as a geological one.
The salon will highlight six Masterpiece High jewelry creations, including the Aurora Collier, Galaxy Collier, Mirage Collier, Bloem Collier, Marina Collier, and the Lillian Collier.
For McKinney, New York marks the culmination of more than two decades in the U.S. After studying in Los Angeles at 17, an unexpected encounter in Las Vegas set her jewelry career in motion. Neiman Marcus became an early, transformative retail partner, followed shortly by Bergdorf Goodman. Along the way, American collectors became friends, and in 2025, Margot opened her first standalone U.S. boutique at The Peninsula Beverly Hills. Now, she embarks on an exciting new chapter in one of the country’s most iconic cities.
The Margot McKinney flagship boutique will be open seven days a week from 11am to 6pm.